2017 Best Corporate Citizens in Canada ranking reveals progress in gender diversity and linking pay to corporate sustainability
TORONTO, June 6, 2017 /CNW/ - Corporate Knights today released the 16th annual ranking of the Best 50 Corporate Citizens in Canada, naming Vancouver City Savings Credit Union the top corporate citizen for the second year in a row. Disclosure practices continued to improve and the country's top corporate citizens raised the bar, though incrementally, towards greater board and executive diversity and a greater number of companies that mandate mechanisms to link CEO compensation with sustainability performance.
Vancity, the largest community credit union in Canada, is no stranger to sustainability leadership or the ranking, having achieved the top position for the past two years as well as in 2013. Amid growing membership and assets under management, Vancity continued to improve its industry-leading standards on waste productivity, CEO-to-average worker pay ratio, executive diversity and employee turnover. "Vancity is honoured to be named Canada's top corporate citizen for the second year in a row," says Vancity President and CEO Tamara Vrooman. "We're very proud of our values-based business model and our commitment to building healthy communities. This award is a great recognition of the work our 2,600 employees do each day to bring this model to life for our members."
"The Best 50 Corporate Citizens define the Canadian standard for which companies are doing the most to advance a more fair and sustainable world," says Corporate Knights CEO Toby Heaps.
The complete ranking appears in the June 6 edition of Corporate Knights magazine (Summer 2017) and online at corporateknights.com. In the same issue, Corporate Knights delves deeper into the key performance indicator for diversity to identify which corporations lead on women's representation on boards and in executive positions across the country. The company with the highest percentage of women in executive positions, and tied for representation on its board, is HSBC Bank Canada, a leading international bank in Canada, and also the third-highest ranking company on the Best 50 overall this year.
To determine the top corporate citizens, Corporate Knights took a rules-based, transparent approach, evaluating 14 key performance indicators (KPIs) to a starting universe of Canadian companies with revenues of at least $2 billion and 2,000 employees in 2016, the 10 largest co-ops, constituents of the TSX 60 and all members of the 2016 Best 50 ranking. This year, Corporate Knights added two additional KPIs, related to supply chain and clean air productivity, to capture increased disclosure practices in these areas from corporate Canada.
The 2017 Best 50 Corporate Citizens in Canada ranking was sponsored by CIPEC – the Canadian Industry Program for Energy Conservation – which helps organizations increase profits by improving energy efficiency and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Appendix A
2017 Corporate Knights Best 50 Corporate Citizens in Canada ranking
2017 Rank |
Name |
GICS Sector |
Overall Score |
1 |
Vancouver City Savings Credit Union |
Financials |
73.78% |
2 |
Desjardins Group |
Financials |
69.39% |
3 |
HSBC Bank Canada |
Financials |
62.80% |
4 |
Hydro-Québec |
Utilities |
62.34% |
5 |
Cameco Corp |
Energy |
61.35% |
6 |
Enbridge Inc |
Energy |
60.56% |
7 |
Royal Bank of Canada |
Financials |
60.09% |
8 |
IGM Financial |
Financials |
58.49% |
9 |
The Co-operators |
Financials |
58.31% |
10 |
Sun Life Financial |
Financials |
57.70% |
11 |
Hydro One Ltd |
Utilities |
57.60% |
12 |
Bank of Montreal |
Financials |
56.85% |
13 |
Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board |
Utilities |
56.01% |
14 |
Enmax Corp |
Utilities |
55.93% |
15 |
Mountain Equipment Co-op |
Consumer discretionary |
55.61% |
16 |
Transat AT Inc |
Industrials |
54.16% |
17 |
Toronto-Dominion Bank |
Financials |
53.81% |
18 |
Teck Resources |
Materials |
53.51% |
19 |
Kinross Gold |
Materials |
52.39% |
20 |
Suncor Energy |
Energy |
50.61% |
21 |
Cenovus Energy |
Energy |
50.33% |
22 |
TC Transcontinental |
Consumer discretionary |
49.68% |
23 |
Agrium Inc |
Materials |
49.42% |
24 |
Celestica Inc |
Information technology |
49.36% |
25 |
Telus Corp |
Telecommunication services |
48.96% |
26 |
Rogers Communications |
Telecommunication services |
47.76% |
27 |
Intact Financial |
Financials |
47.25% |
28 |
CIBC |
Financials |
46.70% |
29 |
Transcanada Corp |
Energy |
46.48% |
30 |
Domtar Corp |
Materials |
45.49% |
31 |
BCE Inc |
Telecommunication services |
45.40% |
32 |
Agnico Eagle Mines |
Materials |
44.83% |
33 |
Ontario Power Generation |
Utilities |
44.65% |
34 |
Bank of Nova Scotia |
Financials |
44.35% |
35 |
Husky Energy Inc |
Energy |
44.12% |
36 |
Cascades Inc |
Materials |
43.99% |
37 |
Aimia Inc |
Consumer discretionary |
43.64% |
38 |
Canadian Tire Corp Ltd |
Consumer discretionary |
43.38% |
39 |
Catalyst Paper Corp |
Materials |
43.05% |
40 |
Capital Power Corp |
Utilities |
41.88% |
41 |
Bombardier Inc |
Industrials |
41.69% |
42 |
Pacific Exploration and Production |
Energy |
41.45% |
43 |
Potash Corp |
Materials |
40.84% |
44 |
National Bank of Canada |
Financials |
40.83% |
45 |
WSP Global Inc |
Industrials |
40.13% |
46 |
Yamana Gold Inc |
Materials |
40.10% |
47 |
Maple Leaf Foods |
Consumer staples |
39.89% |
48 |
Canadian National Railway Co |
Industrials |
39.51% |
49 |
Loblaw Cos Ltd |
Consumer staples |
39.16% |
50 |
Federated Co-operatives Ltd |
Energy |
38.88% |
Appendix B
Canadian corporate sustainability performance over time*
Key findings |
2013 |
2014 |
2015 |
Possible reasons |
Board diversity |
17.5% |
20.6% |
22.5% |
OSC requirement to disclose, diversity campaigns |
Cash tax/EBITDA |
10.6% |
12.9% |
12.5% |
Lax CRA |
CEO-average worker pay |
110 |
105 |
128 |
Short-termism, executive pay consultants benchmarking against questionable peers |
GHG productivity ($ revenue per tonne) |
50,536 |
50,703 |
46,026 |
Energy sector biggest culprit - drop in GHG productivity by 23% over 2014-2015 |
Water productivity ($ revenue per cubic metre) |
11,168 |
10,117 |
8,669 |
Energy, materials, utilities decreased productivity |
Sustainability pay link (out of 60) |
28 |
28 |
33 |
Stakeholder pressure |
*Using the S&P/TSX 60 cohort
SOURCE Corporate Knights Inc.
Toby Heaps, CEO, Corporate Knights, (416) 203-4674, [email protected]
Share this article