BrandSpark Announces Canada's Most Trusted Award Winners for Retailers (Brick & Mortar and E-Commerce) and Service Brands as Voted by Canadians
Over 5000 shoppers named their most trusted brands across 58 categories: 19 major retail,
23 e-commerce retail and 16 service categories in the second annual national study
TORONTO, Oct. 31, 2017 /CNW/ - Market research firm BrandSpark International today announced the 2017 BrandSpark Most Trusted Award winners for Canada's major services and retail categories, including brick and mortar and e-commerce. In spite of recent retail closures and major competition from the U.S., six brick and mortar retailers lead their categories from coast-to-coast, including: Dollarama (discount stores), Canadian Tire (auto parts & accessories), Sleep Country Canada (mattresses), Best Buy (electronics), Walmart (houseware/kitchenware) and Toys "R" Us (toys and games) even though Toys "R" Us recently filed for creditor protection. Details can be found at www.BrandSparkMostTrusted.com.
"Shoppers look to retailers that they trust to deliver great value, strong selection, quality goods, and when online, timely delivery. The BrandSpark Most Trusted Awards give shoppers a chance to see which retailers are trusted by other Canadians," said Robert Levy, President of BrandSpark International. "These endorsements are especially useful for shoppers who don't regularly shop the category – particularly in e-commerce where many shoppers are still discovering the major retail players."
What Drives Brand Trust?
"Canadians say their trust in a brand is greatly increased by personal experience, responsiveness, transparency, fair pricing, and the endorsements of other consumers," said Levy.
It is important that a brand responds quickly to serious issues, with 73% saying it greatly increases their trust in the brand. Transparency is also key to building trust. In fact, 56% agree that brands that provide detailed information about their product or service earn trust, and 49% say trust is built when they see unfiltered customer reviews on the brand web site. A majority of online consumers now seek reviews to support their purchase decisions, and they read both positive and negative reviews to get a more complete picture. Without this information, many shoppers will not complete a transaction.
Positive endorsement in the form of awards is also very impactful with 85% of respondents stating their trust in a brand increases if it has won awards based on the feedback of consumers.
Pricing also influences trust as much as product or service quality, with brands that offer consistent and competitive pricing more likely to be perceived as fair and honest.
In the general retail study, participants named the retailers they trust most across 19 categories.
The winners are listed below.
Brick & Mortar Retail Winners
General Retail Category |
2017 WINNING Retailer |
1st Runner-up |
2nd Runner-up |
Auto Parts & Accessories |
Canadian Tire |
Napa |
Parts Source |
Beauty & Personal Care |
Shoppers Drug Mart / |
Walmart |
Sephora |
Clothing / Fashion |
The Bay / Winners (tie) |
-- |
Walmart |
Department Store |
Walmart |
The Bay |
Sears |
Discount Store (NEW) |
Dollarama |
Walmart |
Giant Tiger |
Electronics |
Best Buy |
The Source |
Walmart |
Furniture |
The Brick / Leon's (tie) |
-- |
Ikea |
Gas Station (NEW) |
Petro-Canada |
Shell |
Esso |
Hardware Store (NEW) |
Home Hardware |
The Home Depot |
Rona |
Health / Pharmacy |
Shoppers Drug Mart / |
Jean Coutu |
Rexall |
Home Décor |
HomeSense |
Winners |
Ikea |
Home Improvement / Hardware |
The Home Depot |
Home Hardware |
Rona |
Housewares / Kitchenware |
Walmart |
Canadian Tire |
Kitchen Stuff Plus |
Major Appliance Retailer (NEW) |
Sears |
The Brick |
The Home Depot |
Mass Merchant |
Walmart |
Costco |
Canadian Tire |
Mattress Retailer (NEW) |
Sleep Country Canada / |
Sears |
The Brick |
Sporting Goods |
Sport Chek |
Canadian Tire |
Sports Experts |
Supermarket / Grocery |
Real Canadian Superstore |
No Frills |
Metro |
Toys & Games |
Toys "R" Us |
Walmart |
Mastermind Toys |
The Canadian retail landscape is dotted with strong regional players and the most trusted retailers vary across Canada in many categories. This is particularly true for Quebec, where home-grown retailers are often most trusted.
Six retailers lead their categories from coast-to-coast, including Dollarama (discount stores), Canadian Tire (auto parts & accessories), Sleep Country Canada (mattresses), Best Buy (electronics), Walmart (houseware/kitchenware) and Toys "R" Us (toys and games) even though Toys "R" Us recently filed for creditor protection.
Regional players are strong in Quebec, including Brault & Martineau for furniture and major appliances, Bouclair for home décor (in a tie), and Jean Coutu for beauty & personal care and health/pharmacy. While in the rest of Canada Home Depot is on top for home improvement (or tied in the Atlantic region), Rona is most trusted in Quebec.
The grocery landscape also changes by region. Loblaw brands are strong with the Superstore brand (Real Canadian Superstore and Atlantic Superstore) on top nationally, anchored by a leading position in the Western provinces and No Frills earns top spot in Ontario. In Quebec, IGA and Maxi tie. Sobeys is most trusted in Atlantic Canada.
Sears shows up as the most trusted retailer for major appliances. "Now that Sears has decided to liquidate all of its stores and cease operations in Canada we can expect fierce competition from other retailers to fill the void. This could present some great opportunities for Canadian shoppers," added Levy.
E-Commerce Retail Winners
Canadian shopping habits are evolving. According to the BrandSpark Canadian Shopper Study, seven in ten Canadians shop online in a typical month and online shoppers expect to make a larger share of purchases online in the coming year.
"As the retailers that Canadian shoppers know and trust continue to build their presence on
e-commerce, we expect to see trusted brick and mortar brands become more prominent online.
To succeed in the transition to e-commerce, retailers must deliver online the value and experience that has made them trusted offline, while also meeting the high expectations of online shipping and no hassle customer service and returns set by the e-commerce leader Amazon," said Levy.
In the BrandSpark Most Trusted Online Retail Study, shoppers specifically named the retailers online that they trust most across 23 retail categories. Listed below are the national winners.
E-Commerce Category |
2017 WINNING Retailer |
1st Runner-up |
2nd Runner-up |
Auto Parts & Accessories |
Amazon |
Canadian Tire |
eBay |
Baby & Children's Clothing |
The Children's Place |
Old Navy |
Carter's |
Beauty Products / Cosmetics |
Sephora |
Amazon |
Avon |
Books |
Amazon |
Chapters/Indigo |
Kobo |
Electronic Gaming / Videogames |
Amazon |
Best Buy |
EB Games |
Electronics |
Amazon |
Best Buy |
eBay |
Flights |
WestJet / Expedia (tie) |
-- |
Air Canada |
Food & Beverage (non-perishable) |
Amazon |
Walmart |
Well.ca |
Grocery / Fresh Food |
Walmart |
Real Canadian |
Amazon |
Health & Wellness |
Amazon |
Well.ca |
Walmart |
Home Appliances |
Amazon |
Best Buy |
The Home Depot |
Home Decor |
Amazon |
Wayfair |
Ikea |
Home Improvement / Renovation |
The Home Depot |
Amazon |
Rona |
Housewares / Kitchenwares |
Amazon |
Walmart |
The Bay |
Laptop/Desktop Computers |
Best Buy |
Dell |
Amazon |
Men's Clothing / Fashion |
Amazon |
Old Navy |
The Bay |
Personal Care |
Amazon |
Well.ca |
Walmart |
Pet Care |
Amazon |
PetSmart |
Walmart |
Shoes / Footwear |
Amazon |
The Bay |
Sport Chek |
Sporting Goods |
Amazon |
Sport Chek |
MEC |
Toys & Games |
Amazon |
Toys"R"Us |
Walmart |
Travel / Accommodation |
Expedia |
Trivago |
Hotels.com |
Women's Clothing / Fashion |
Old Navy / Reitmans |
-- |
The Bay |
When Canadians shop online, Amazon is the most likely destination for a wide range of products. Walmart is close behind for food and beverage products. "With the recent acquisition of Whole Foods by Amazon, the grocery category is expected to become very competitive in the next few years," added Levy.
Although Amazon is top-of-mind for e-commerce, several specialized retailers have been successful, including: Sephora (beauty products & cosmetics), Well.ca (health & wellness), PetSmart (pet care), and Home Depot (home improvement & renovations). These retailers lead their categories or are competing closely with Amazon.
"If other retailers want to catch up with Amazon in their category, they need to stay top-of-mind as their customers move online, and deliver the online browsing experience, selection, value, and service required to be shoppers' go-to destination in the category," said Levy. "Amazon's leadership in voice-activated shopping will make it even harder for traditional retailers to catch up."
Most Trusted Services Brands
For the first time, the BrandSpark Most Trusted Awards program has been expanded to service categories where trust matters greatly to Canadians. Winners are listed below.
Service Category |
2017 |
1st Runner-up |
2nd Runner-up |
Airline |
WestJet |
Air Canada |
Air Transat |
Alarm Service |
ADT Security Services |
AlarmForce |
Vivint |
Auto Insurance |
Intact Insurance |
ICBC |
Belairdirect |
Bank |
RBC / TD |
-- |
Scotiabank |
Car Rental |
Enterprise |
Budget |
Avis |
Credit Card |
Visa |
Mastercard |
RBC |
Dating Site |
POF |
Tinder |
Match |
Home Insurance |
Intact Insurance |
The Co-operators |
Wawanesa Insurance |
Hotel |
Best Western/ Hilton/ Marriott |
-- |
-- |
Internet Provider |
Bell |
Shaw |
Rogers |
Life Insurance |
Sun Life Financial |
Manulife |
London Life |
Loyalty Program |
Air Miles |
PC Plus |
Shoppers Optimum |
Mobile Telecom |
Telus |
Rogers |
Bell |
Online Banking |
RBC / TD |
-- |
Scotiabank |
Real Estate |
RE/MAX |
Royal LePage |
Century 21 |
TV Service |
Shaw / Bell |
-- |
Rogers |
In the airline category, both WestJet and Air Canada are trusted by Canadian consumers who largely prefer booking flights with Canadian airlines. "In fact, WestJet is propelled by its advantage in Western Canada," added Levy.
In the insurance categories (home, auto and life), Intact Insurance comes out on top with their Canada-wide service in auto and home insurance while Sun Life is the leader in life insurance with Manulife being a strong runner-up.
In the competitive banking space RBC and TD are tied as Canadians turn more to online banking. In the car rental category Enterprise Car Rental comes out on top, followed by budget-minded Budget, and service-led Avis.
Despite recent controversy, Air Miles is still valued by many Canadians as the top loyalty program especially by those who can realize larger point gains via credit cards. In fact, everyday retail programs are gaining more importance with PC Plus and Shoppers Optimum rounding out the top three in this category.
In the ever-expanding world of online dating, despite the rapid rise of Tinder, when it comes to trust Canadians cast their nets with Plenty of Fish.
The area where geographic location plays a strong role is in the telecom categories with clear regional splits that sees Telus identified as more trusted than Rogers and Bell. In the internet provider category Bell comes out just ahead of Shaw and Rogers nationally. For television service, Shaw catches up to Bell with Rogers being the runner-up.
In an increasingly fragmented real estate market filled with boutique players, national giant RE/MAX has maintained a dominant position, ahead of runner-ups Royal LePage and Century 21.
How Winners are Determined
More than 5,000 respondents surveyed in 2017 determined the 2017 BrandSpark Most Trusted Awards retail winners through their "top of mind" responses for retail and services categories in which they shop. BrandSpark researchers analyzed the unaided responses and the reasons for trusting the retailer or service. Results were ranked based on the greatest volume of mentions, and if the difference between retailers or services nationally was less than three percent, ties were declared.
About BrandSpark International
BrandSpark International uniquely combines real world consumer insight with marketing credentials and services. BrandSpark Insight gets at the heart of WHAT consumers think, WHY they act the way they do, and HOW marketers need to respond to successfully grow their business. BrandSpark Marketing Services runs major CPG awards programs Best New Product Awards, BrandSpark Most Trusted Awards and consumer product trial and amplification platform, Shopper Army. For more information, visit www.BrandSpark.com.
SOURCE BrandSpark International
For more information or interview requests, please contact: BrandSpark International, Robert Levy, President, [email protected]; Philip Scrutton, VP Shopper Insights, [email protected]
Share this article